Success factor 1 of 6
Problem in the Lean Progress Model: Is it relevant?
Guiding question: Is it relevant?
The first success factor checks whether the problem you want to solve is really relevant to your potential customers.
Why start with the problem?
An innovation can only be successful if it solves a problem that has not been solved yet, has not been solved satisfactorily enough, or can be solved fundamentally better. A problem is only a good one if it is relevant to potential customers. If they do not see the problem or it is not important enough, they will not care about a much better solution either. If the problem is relevant, customers are usually open to new solutions.
What makes a good problem?
The more important the problem is from the customer perspective and the more actively customers have already looked for a solution, the better the chances of success. The problem-applicability pyramid (after Blank et al., 2013) helps you judge this. From bottom to top, potential customers have a problem, are aware of the problem, actively look for a solution, build a solution themselves and have a budget. The higher your customers rank on the pyramid, the better.
Intensity and frequency count too: the longer, more often and more extensively a problem occurs, the sooner it needs to be solved, and the longer, more often and more extensively the solution will be used.
Why the term "problem"?
In the book I argue for using the word "problem" in startup and innovation projects, in a neutral sense. It makes a situation feel more important and concrete than "challenge" or "need". Every challenge and need can be phrased as a problem. And it keeps us from looking for a need for our solution instead of the other way around.
The twelve sub-questions
- How relevant is the problem for potential customers?
- Are potential customers aware of the problem?
- How often and for how long has the problem been happening?
- How much of a pain and how extreme is the problem?
- How much more of a positive impact would a better solution have?
- Have potential customers already looked for a solution?
- Have potential customers already tried to solve the problem themselves?
- Are potential customers enthusiastic with respect to the problem?
- Are potential customers enthusiastic with respect to a new solution?
- Which key problem is the focus and what are the lower-level problems?
- Which aspects of the problem do we still need to better understand?
- Are there related problems that we still need to take into consideration?
These questions set the direction. You prioritize them by risk and answer first what matters most for your project.
How to read the colors: Problem
- Red The problem is not a problem, or it is not important enough. Potential customers are fairly happy with the current situation and have no wish to help with development or to learn about new solutions.
- Yellow Customers have a problem or are only moderately satisfied, but do not know exactly which problem needs solving. They are open to new things, but have neither actively looked for a solution nor developed one themselves, and they do not react enthusiastically.
- Green Potential customers react very enthusiastically to the prospect of a new, better solution to a very clear problem.
The six success factors
- ProblemIs it relevant?
- SolutionIs it better?
- PotentialIs it worth it?
- ViabilityCan and do we want to embark on the business venture?
- ScalabilityCan we grow quickly and efficiently enough?
- TractionIs the customer response positive enough?
The model in the book and as a poster
The Lean Innovation Guide takes you through all six success factors step by step. The model is also available as a free poster.